Case Study  ·  Vendor Evaluation

Replacing a 20-year system with confidence.

A premium automotive aftermarket products manufacturer wanted to replace its legacy ERP system with a modern platform. Prescouter interviewed 15+ stakeholders, mapped dependencies across connected systems and ran structured demonstrations with 5 ERP vendors.

The Client

The client is a manufacturer of premium automotive aftermarket products, specializing in car care formulations and detailing solutions. It wanted real-time data visibility, automated workflows and integrated planning to support growth.

The Challenge

Twenty years of workarounds.
One new system.

The client needed comprehensive requirements across finance, supply chain, manufacturing and research, a map of 15+ connected systems with limited documentation and a fair way to compare ERP vendors.

  • Requirements

    Every function heard

    Current needs and future growth.

  • Integration

    15+ connected systems

    Undocumented data flows mapped.

  • Selection

    Consistent criteria

    Vendors compared like for like.

Our Approach

Multi-phase discovery, structured vendor demos.

Stakeholder interviews
15+stakeholders interviewed

Hear every function

Remote and on-site interviews captured workflows, pain points and requirements by department.

Systems mapping
15+connected systems mapped

Map the dependencies

Data flows and integrations with the legacy system were documented, alongside an interactive dashboard.

Vendor evaluation
5ERP vendors assessed

Compare the options

Structured demonstrations were scored against documented requirements, validated by ERP experts.

The Outcome

Leadership aligned on a recommended shortlist.

Prescouter delivered detailed requirements analysis and vendor assessments to support replacing the client's 20+ year legacy ERP system. The engagement unified input from numerous stakeholders, mapped dependencies across connected systems and evaluated five vendors. The steering committee and executive leadership are fully aligned and expect to select a vendor from the recommended shortlist.

  • Alignment

    One set of priorities

    Competing requirements reconciled.

  • Clarity

    Dependencies documented

    No hidden integration surprises.

  • Decision

    A vetted shortlist

    Ready for final vendor selection.

ERP projects rarely fail on software. They fail on undocumented workflows and unresolved priorities, which is why discovery matters as much as selection.

Let’s Talk

Is your next system choice built on evidence?

Capture requirements, map dependencies and evaluate vendors with a structured, unbiased process. Wherever you’re starting from, we’ll help you get there.

Or email [email protected]

Book a Session

Want to skip the email back-and-forth?

Pick a time on our calendar right now.

If you’d like to know the outcome of your submission, please leave your email address