Complexity kills simple answers

We analyzed 40+ pathways and discovered why every “best option” failed somewhere.

Hi there and happy Wednesday,

Most people think waste is a simple problem.

You throw something away. Someone deals with it.

But the moment you ask what should happen next, the answers get complicated fast.

Burn it? Recycle it? Convert it into fuel? Capture emissions? Send it to the landfill?

Every option comes with tradeoffs. Cost. Emissions. Infrastructure. Market demand. Energy use. Regulation.

That is the challenge a waste management and turnkey solutions provider was facing. They wanted a clear answer to a deceptively simple question:

What is the best way to process municipal solid waste?

That question sounds simple until every option starts optimizing for something different. One pathway lowers emissions. Another improves profitability. A third works better at scale but depends on additional infrastructure and processing steps.

They came to us to evaluate which waste-processing routes actually made sense once the technical, environmental, and economic tradeoffs were measured together.

The 3-step approach we used to compare waste processing pathways

Here’s what we did.

Step 1: Map every realistic processing route

We started by identifying the major waste processing methods and the combinations connected to them.

This included:

  • Incineration
  • Anaerobic digestion
  • Gasification
  • (all) Plastic recycling and plastic-to-fuel pathways
  • Landfill pathways
  • Carbon capture integrations
  • Hydrogen generation and energy recovery systems

In total, more than 40 different pathway combinations were mapped and evaluated.

Step 2: Gather the inputs behind the claims

Next, we collected the technical and economic inputs needed to compare these pathways properly.

This included:

  • Direct and indirect GHG emissions
  • Capital and operational costs
  • Revenue potential
  • Carbon credits and taxes
  • Energy outputs
  • Waste sorting and processing requirements

The goal was to move beyond broad assumptions and quantify the tradeoffs.

Step 3: Build a decision model around real calculations

The final step was turning the data into a working model.

Mass and energy balances were performed across the different pathways to understand where emissions, materials, costs, and revenues were actually going.

This allowed the client to compare processing routes side by side using measurable technical and economic metrics.

Results

The analysis gave the client a structured way to evaluate which waste processing methods made the most sense under different conditions.

Key outcomes included:

  • Comparison of more than 40 waste processing pathway combinations
  • Identification of the most environmentally and economically attractive routes
  • Visibility into the tradeoffs across emissions, profitability, and scalability
  • A reusable decision model that could be updated as technologies evolved

The findings helped the client move forward with specific developments while avoiding lower-value pathways.

What you can learn from this

Across industries, complex decisions often become oversimplified once strong opinions take over.

The problem is rarely the lack of options. It is the lack of a clear way to compare them.

When technical, operational, environmental, and economic variables start interacting, assumptions stop being reliable.

Teams that build decision frameworks around real tradeoffs make better long-term bets.

If your next strategic decision involves competing technologies, the quality of the comparison matters as much as the technologies themselves.

Ready to evaluate which pathways actually make sense?

Contributing expert - Christian Salles

Contact our team

Email our team

Or open a new message

About the author

Never miss an insight
Get insights delivered right to your inbox

Book a Session

Want to skip the email back-and-forth?

Pick a time on our calendar right now.

If you’d like to know the outcome of your submission, please leave your email address