How to run a tech scan that leads to a decision

TECH SCOUTING

3 steps to evaluate emerging technologies with more confidence.

Hi,

New startups, breakthroughs, patents, and technologies are emerging faster than teams can evaluate them. More possibilities don't necessarily mean better decisions.

After hundreds of technology scouting projects, we've found that the strongest teams don't just identify what's new. They know which technologies are credible, commercially relevant, and worth pursuing.

The difference? A better way to evaluate what they find.

THE FRAMEWORK

What every technology evaluation should include

Rather than explain these principles in the abstract, here's how three of them shaped a scouting project for a major oil and gas company evaluating green hydrogen investments.

01

STEP

Start with the decision, not the technology

A common place to begin is: what's the newest technology in this space?

Reasonable, but rarely the most useful starting point. The better question is what business decision the evaluation needs to support:

  • Reduce manufacturing costs?
  • Improve sustainability performance?
  • Develop a new product?
  • Identify acquisition or investment targets?

Each objective changes how technologies should be assessed. Without a defined decision, even promising innovations are hard to compare, because nothing anchors what "better" means. The business decision should define the criteria, not the other way around.

IN PRACTICE

The objective was never to catalogue every electrolyzer on the market. The client wanted technologies capable of a step change over incumbent solutions, not incremental gains. That single decision shaped the entire evaluation, producing a framework that held commercially available technologies and longer-term breakthrough candidates to different standards.

02

STEP

Validate before you compare

Once candidate technologies have been identified, the instinct is to compare vendors. Don't. Validate each technology independently first:

  • Has it moved beyond laboratory testing?
  • What evidence supports its performance claims?
  • Can it scale commercially?
  • What technical risks remain?
  • What barriers could slow adoption?

Only after those questions are answered does comparison mean anything.

IN PRACTICE

Four electrolysis pathways (AEL, PEM, SOEC and AEMWE) were assessed on their own terms before any comparison. We combined technical literature, vendor materials and expert interviews, then spoke directly with seven companies selected from more than 30 identified vendors. Those conversations existed to test where public claims held up against real-world performance.

03

STEP

Use a consistent evaluation framework

Consistency drives better technology decisions more than almost anything else. Every technology should be measured against the same criteria. Projects differ, but most assessments consider:

  • Technology readiness level (TRL)
  • Technical feasibility
  • Commercial potential
  • Competitive positioning
  • Scalability
  • Strategic fit
  • Capability of the technology provider

The objective isn't a scorecard. It's an evidence base where the differences reflect the technologies, not uneven research.

IN PRACTICE

The framework came down to four investment criteria: efficiency, capital investment requirements, operating temperature, and projected future hydrogen price. Applied consistently, they exposed differences that the initial market landscape had hidden, where several technologies looked equally attractive.

GREEN HYDROGEN CASE STUDY

How 30+ vendors became a two-horizon investment portfolio

Technology scouting for a major oil and gas client evaluating electrolysis

A question worth asking

Traditional market research tells you what's happening, who's entering the market and which companies are growing. Valuable signals, but they rarely answer what actually gates an investment.

So the strongest innovation teams we work with challenge their own evaluation process, not just the technologies they're tracking. Five questions worth putting to your team:

  1. Are we validating technologies, or just tracking trends?
  2. How do we tell technical promise from commercial readiness?
  3. Are we comparing every opportunity against the same criteria?
  4. Which innovations deserve attention now, and which can wait?
  5. Could stronger solutions be sitting outside the places we usually look?

Sometimes improving the process creates more value than expanding the search.

Emerging technologies will only become more abundant. That won't be the advantage. Knowing which ones deserve investment, and having a disciplined way to reach that conclusion, will be.

If any of this sparked ideas for your own process, we'd like to hear how your team approaches technology evaluation.

About the author

Never miss an insight
Get insights delivered right to your inbox

Book a Session

Want to skip the email back-and-forth?

Pick a time on our calendar right now.

If you’d like to know the outcome of your submission, please leave your email address