How one cookie put 90 manufacturers to the test

CASE STUDY

A look at how we checked supplier capabilities and found six manufacturers in six weeks.

Hi there and happy Thursday,

Every manufacturer’s website says they can make it.

Custom formats. Flexible runs. Fast turnaround. Read enough of them and you’d think your new product could go into production next month with almost anyone.

Most of the time, nobody tests that. The capabilities page lists the right equipment, the website says yes, and the supplier goes on the shortlist.

A Fortune 500 food company didn’t have time to find out the slow way. Its R&D team had a novel cookie ready to commercialize, and it needed a contract manufacturer to make it. Urgently.

That changes the question. With time on your side, you can absorb a partner that turns out to be the wrong fit. Without it, every false start costs weeks you don’t have.

So their question wasn’t who makes cookies. Plenty of companies do. It was who could make this cookie, on this timeline, and actually deliver.

Chart showing most manufacturers that look right on paper can’t make the product

Here’s how we found out.

THE APPROACH

How we got from 90 to 6 in about six weeks

01

THE LONG LIST

Start with everyone who says they can

The first step was deliberately wide. Working with the client’s R&D team, we used desk research to map and profile contract manufacturers based on the capabilities they advertise.

That gave us 90 candidates.

For a lot of teams, this is where the search ends. Ninety names in a spreadsheet looks like a market full of options.

But everything on that list came from the manufacturers themselves. It tells you who says they can make your product. It can’t tell you who actually can.

So the next job was to start cutting.

02

THE FIRST GATE

Narrow it down on paper

We ran the search as a two-step, stage-gated process, and the first gate was on paper.

Each of the 90 was ranked on how closely its advertised capabilities matched what the client’s cookie needed. The best fits moved forward. The rest stopped there.

46 made it through, about half the list.

That gate matters because calls are expensive. Each one takes time on both sides, and on a tight deadline you can’t spend it on a manufacturer that was never a real option.

But a good fit on paper is still only a claim. The phone calls were where it got tested.

03

THE PHONE CALLS

Ask directly, without saying who’s asking

Next, we interviewed all 46, and kept our client anonymous the whole way through.

That matters more than it sounds. A supplier talking to an unnamed buyer has no reason to stretch. It gives you the plain answer, not the pitch it would make to a Fortune 500 account it’s keen to win.

Each call had one job: confirm the details and capabilities a website can’t. In practice, that comes down to a few blunt questions:

Can you make this exact product, not just something like it?
Do you have room to take it on now?
Can you meet the specs and quality standards?
And can you do it on this timeline?

A website can answer the first one, in theory. Only a conversation answers the rest.

04

THE SHORTLIST

Six that could actually do it

Out of 46 conversations, 6 manufacturers were confirmed as able to make the client’s product.

Think about what that means. These weren’t random names. Every one of the 46 had already passed the paper review. Even so, only about 1 in 8 calls ended in a confirmed yes.

Against the original list, it’s roughly 1 in 15. The whole process, from first search to final shortlist, took about six weeks.

The client came away with six manufacturers it could approach with confidence, instead of ninety it would have had to work through one by one.

Ninety looked right. Six were.

Cookies on a production line conveyor

WHERE THIS SHOWS UP ELSEWHERE

What a supplier advertises isn’t what it can do

The cookie isn’t the point.

The same gap shows up whenever you need an outside partner quickly: a co-packer, a toll compounder, a specialty chemical supplier, a testing lab. The list of companies that say they can help is always longer than the list that can.

It isn’t a one-off, either. When we’ve run similar searches for other food and beverage teams, the drop-off looks much the same. For a ready-to-drink supplement beverage, 35+ manufacturers became 22 calls and 7 confirmed partners. For a line of supplement gummies, 55+ became 22 calls and 6.

The teams that move fastest aren’t the ones with the longest list. They’re the ones that find out early which names are real.

Three questions worth asking your team:

  1. When we shortlist partners, how many have we actually spoken to?
  2. Do suppliers know it’s us asking, and does that change what they tell us?
  3. If our first-choice partner fell through tomorrow, how long would it take to find the next one?

NEXT STEP

Need a partner who can actually deliver?

If you’re launching a product and need a manufacturer, supplier or partner you can count on, we can help you find out who’s real before you commit. A 30-minute conversation with a Prescouter research lead, no commitment.

Until next time,
The Prescouter Team

About the author

Never miss an insight
Get insights delivered right to your inbox

Book a Session

Want to skip the email back-and-forth?

Pick a time on our calendar right now.

If you’d like to know the outcome of your submission, please leave your email address